In a thrilling World Cup 2023 match in Delhi, Bangladesh’s captain, Shakib Al Hasan, sparked controversy and refused to backtrack on a contentious decision. Here’s the story behind the uproar:

During the match, Shakib appealed for a timed-out dismissal against Angelo Mathews. Despite being urged by experienced umpires Marais Erasmus and Richard Illingworth to withdraw the appeal, Shakib stood his ground. Even the fourth umpire, Adrian Holdstock, inquired twice if Shakib would reconsider, but he remained resolute in his decision. Consequently, Mathews became the first cricketer in international cricket history to be given a timed-out dismissal.

The controversial call hinged on Rule 40.1.1 of the ICC’s playing conditions, which state that after a wicket falls or a batter retires, the incoming batter must be prepared to receive the next ball within two minutes of the dismissal or retirement, unless time has been called. Failure to meet this requirement will result in a timed-out dismissal.

Shakib defended his actions, emphasizing that he was merely following the rules of the game. When questioned about the spirit of cricket, he suggested that those who take issue with the decision should petition the ICC to amend the rules. In a post-match press conference, he asserted,

“I appealed to the umpires…I won’t call him back.”

He continued,

“It’s in the laws. I don’t know if it’s right or wrong, but I had to make a decision to make sure that my team wins, and whatever I had to do, I have to do it.”

Shakib’s performance in the match was stellar, earning him the Player of the Match title for his 82 runs off 65 balls and 2/57 with the ball.

The controversy unfolded during the 25th over of the Sri Lankan innings. Mathews, due to a broken helmet strap, wasn’t ready to face his first ball within two minutes of the previous dismissal. Despite his quick actions to replace the helmet, more than three minutes had passed. When Bangladesh appealed, the on-field umpires decided not to retract the appeal, leading to Mathews’ dismissal, much to the dismay of the Sri Lankan team.

Mathews disagreed with the fourth umpire’s account, claiming that the Sri Lankan team possessed visual evidence showing that he had five seconds left on the clock when he reached the crease. He defended his actions, asserting the importance of player safety and common sense.

As far as the match was concerned, Bangladesh successfully chased down Sri Lanka’s target of 280 runs with 8.5 overs to spare, securing a victory with seven wickets in hand. The clash will undoubtedly be remembered for the contentious timed-out dismissal and the steadfastness of Shakib Al Hasan.